The best part: it's very soft and spinny. It isn't too short, like a LOT of fun D&D skirts are, though I do wish it were just a LITTLE longer, but that's just me.
The not so great: It isn't actually black, it's more of a very dark grey. Also, the waistband has little to no give at seam between it and the main spinny skirt, so since I guessed smaller rather than larger on the sizing, I have to be careful getting it over my hips. That or I have to pull it over my head.
The bad: The stitching is was frayed and not well done when I got it. Also, the sizing chart is awful. No one can measure how wide they are!
Suggestions: Get your size chart set up by waist circumference size. Fix your stitching issues somehow. Maybe fix your colors online so it relects the real colors or the physical product to actually be black. Either one would be good.